When to Switch from Cash to Accrual Accounting: Key Insights for SMBs

When to switch from cash to accrual accounting is typically when your small or midsize business needs more accurate financial visibility—often triggered by revenue growth past $1 million, inventory requirements, or external financing demands. By recognizing income and expenses when they occur rather than when cash changes hands, accrual accounting equips you to make data-driven decisions and maintain compliance with lenders or investors.

Have you noticed your business growing more complex? Perhaps tracking receivables has become challenging, or maybe you’re considering applying for larger loans. These growing pains aren’t just operational headaches—they’re signals that your accounting method needs to evolve alongside your business ambitions.

What triggers the switch from cash to accrual accounting?

• Revenue growth past $1 million, complex inventory management, financing needs, and compliance requirements typically trigger the switch
• Businesses handling inventory should use accrual accounting to accurately track cost of goods sold and profit margins
• Companies seeking external financing must provide GAAP-compliant financial statements, which require accrual-based reporting
• The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act allows businesses with less than $25 million in gross receipts to use cash accounting, but many outgrow this method’s capabilities
• Signs like increasing accounts receivable complexity and lengthening sales cycles indicate your business has outgrown cash accounting

Understanding Cash Accounting vs Accrual Accounting

Making the right accounting method choice impacts everything from tax planning to investor relationships. The foundation of this decision begins with understanding the key differences between these two approaches.

Defining cash accounting vs accrual accounting

Cash accounting records transactions only when money physically changes hands. You record revenue when customers pay you and expenses when you pay bills—simple and straightforward.

Accrual accounting recognizes revenue when earned and expenses when incurred, regardless of when money moves. This creates a more accurate picture of your business performance by matching revenue with related expenses in the same period.

The cash accounting vs accrual accounting debate isn’t new, but understanding when each serves your business best is crucial. While cash accounting works well for service-based microbusinesses with immediate payment terms, accrual accounting becomes essential as operations grow more complex.

Accrual accounting vs cash basis: pros and cons

Cash basis advantages:

• Simplicity and low maintenance
• Immediate view of cash position
• Potentially beneficial tax timing
• Lower accounting costs

Cash basis disadvantages:

• Misleading profit picture during growth
• Difficulty tracking accounts receivable trends
• Limited visibility into future obligations
• May not satisfy lender requirements

Accrual advantages:

• Clear visibility of future cash flows
• Accurate matching of revenue and expenses
• Compliant with GAAP requirements
• Better business performance insights

Accrual disadvantages:

• More complex record-keeping
• Potential tax timing complications
• Additional reconciliation requirements
• Higher accounting resource needs

Cash basis accounting advantages—and when they fall short

For startups and small service businesses, cash accounting offers compelling simplicity. You see exactly what’s in your bank account without accounting abstractions. This clarity helps new entrepreneurs understand their immediate cash position and make quick decisions.

However, these cash basis accounting advantages erode as your business develops:

• Inventory management becomes misleading when you expense items upon purchase rather than when sold
• Large contracts with milestone payments create distorted profit pictures
• Growing accounts receivable aren’t reflected in your financial statements
• Multi-period projects become impossible to track accurately

According to the IRS, businesses with inventory or exceeding certain revenue thresholds must use accounting methods for businesses that include accrual accounting for certain aspects of operations.

Signs It’s Time to Switch from Cash to Accrual Accounting

Recognizing the right moment to transition is critical for your business’s financial health and future growth. Here are the tell-tale indicators that your company has outgrown cash-basis accounting.

Signs it’s time to switch to accrual accounting

Look for these clear signs it’s time to switch to accrual accounting:

1. Revenue exceeds $1 million annually – At this scale, financial complexities typically increase exponentially
2. Accounts receivable represent 10%+ of annual revenue – Cash accounting fails to track this significant asset
3. You maintain significant inventory levels – Without accrual, you can’t accurately track the cost of goods sold
4. Sales cycles exceed 30 days – Long payment terms create growing discrepancies between work and payment
5. You’re seeking financing or investors – Most lenders require accrual-based statements for loans over $500,000

When 30% of surveyed jurisdictions used accrual accounting in 2020, projections indicated this would increase to 50% by 2025—reflecting a broad recognition of accruals’ advantages for complex operations.

When to use accrual accounting for revenue recognition

When to use accrual accounting becomes particularly critical for revenue recognition in several common business scenarios:

• Subscription-based businesses need to recognize revenue over service periods
• Construction or project-based companies with milestone billing require matching costs to related revenue
• Professional service firms with retainer arrangements need to track service delivery against prepayments
• Software companies with implementation and ongoing support components must allocate revenue appropriately

The five-step revenue recognition model under FASB ASC 606 applies specifically to accrual accounting, helping businesses appropriately time revenue recognition based on performance obligations rather than payment timing.

External pressures: Lender, investor & compliance demands

External stakeholders often drive the transition to accrual accounting:

• Bank loan covenants typically require GAAP-compliant financial statements
• Investors performing due diligence expect accrual-based financials for accurate company valuation
• Potential acquirers need consistent financial data for proper business valuation
• Growth-stage funding almost universally requires accrual accounting
• The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act increased the gross receipts threshold to $25 million for cash accounting eligibility, but most lenders still require accrual statements for significant financing

According to the Small Business Administration, businesses seeking financing above certain thresholds must provide accrual-based financials that comply with generally accepted accounting principles.

Benefits of Accrual Accounting for Small Businesses

The strategic advantages of accrual accounting extend far beyond compliance, delivering powerful insights that drive smarter business decisions.

Benefits of accrual accounting

The primary benefits of accrual accounting include:

• True profitability measurement – Match revenues with the expenses incurred to generate them
• Accurate trend analysis – Spot seasonal patterns and growth trajectories without cash timing distortions
• Better budgeting and forecasting – Build more reliable projections based on actual business activities
• Enhanced cash flow management – Anticipate cash needs by seeing obligations before they impact your bank account
• Improved decision-making – Access reliable data about product line profitability and customer acquisition costs

A striking 90% of small businesses are affected by late payments, leading to significant operational disruptions. Accrual accounting helps manage this reality by providing visibility into pending receivables and payables.

Accrual accounting for small businesses—Real-world impact

Accrual accounting for small businesses creates tangible improvements:

TechGadget Inc., a company specializing in innovative tech products, implemented accrual accounting during their growth phase. This method provided a clearer picture of product launch profitability over time, rather than just tracking initial cash influx. The result was more strategic inventory purchasing and improved cash flow management.

Similarly, service businesses report that accrual methods help them:

• Identify which clients generate true profit (not just revenue)
• Determine accurate billable hour efficiency
• Plan staffing needs based on upcoming project requirements
• Manage cash reserves more effectively

Cost-benefit snapshot—Is the investment worth it?

Transitioning to accrual accounting requires investment, but the returns typically justify the costs:

Implementation costs:

• Accounting software upgrades: $1,000-5,000
• Staff training: 20-40 hours of team time
• Potential consulting support: $2,000-10,000
• Temporary reduction in reporting speed: 2-3 months

Ongoing benefits:

• 20% faster cash-flow forecasting (TechCo case study)
• 30% reduction in month-end close time
• Cleaner audit trails for lender reviews
• Enhanced ability to identify profit leaks

In one client case study, a C-Corporation transitioning to accrual accounting identified a $530,000 adjustment due to the difference between accounts payable ($830,000) and receivables ($300,000). While this created a one-time tax benefit, the lasting advantage was much clearer visibility into actual business performance.

How to Implement Accrual Accounting Effectively

A successful transition requires careful planning and execution. Follow these steps to ensure your switch to accrual accounting delivers maximum value with minimal disruption.

Transitioning to accrual accounting in 5 phases

The transitioning to accrual accounting process works best when broken into manageable phases:

Phase 1: Assessment & Goal-Setting (2-3 weeks)

• Evaluate current accounting processes and systems
• Define specific objectives for the transition
• Identify key stakeholders and secure their buy-in
• Document current accounting policies and procedures

Phase 2: System Selection and Setup (3-4 weeks)

• Choose appropriate accounting software with accrual capabilities
• Configure the chart of accounts to support accrual method
• Set up recurring journal entries for common accruals
• Establish new approval workflows for revenue/expense recognition

Phase 3: Team Training & Process Mapping (2-3 weeks)

• Train the accounting team on accrual principles
• Develop standard operating procedures for monthly close
• Create documentation for revenue recognition policies
• Establish clear roles and responsibilities

Phase 4: Parallel Run and Reconciliation (4-6 weeks)

• Maintain both cash and accrual records temporarily
• Reconcile differences and address discrepancies
• Test financial reporting and validate outputs
• Fine-tune processes based on findings

Phase 5: Go-Live & Review (Ongoing)

• Fully transition to accrual accounting
• Implement regular review procedures
• Establish continuous improvement protocols
• Document lessons learned for future reference

Switch to accrual accounting timeline

A typical switch to accrual accounting timeline spans 90 days:

Days 1-15: Planning

• Finalize project scope and objectives
• Secure necessary resources and budget
• Develop a detailed implementation schedule
• Conduct initial staff training

Days 16-45: Preparation

• Configure accounting systems
• Develop new policies and procedures
• Complete comprehensive team training
• Begin capturing accrual data alongside cash records

Days 46-75: Transition

• Run parallel accounting systems
• Reconcile and validate results
• Refine processes based on findings
• Prepare for cutover to accrual-only

Days 76-90: Cutover

• Complete final reconciliations
• Transition to accrual-only accounting
• Verify reporting accuracy
• Document transition completion

Post-Implementation (Ongoing)

• Conduct 30/60/90-day review meetings
• Address any emerging issues
• Refine processes for efficiency
• Measure performance against goals

How to implement accrual accounting effectively

To implement accrual accounting effectively, focus on these best practices:

1. Redesign your chart of accounts to accommodate accrual-specific accounts
2. Establish clear revenue recognition policies aligned with your business model
3. Create standardized journal entry templates for common accruals
4. Develop a robust month-end close checklist that captures all necessary accruals
5. Implement enhanced cash flow forecasting that leverages accrual data
6. Train non-financial managers to understand accrual-based reports

The most successful implementations involve both accounting teams and operational leaders to ensure new processes align with business realities.

Accounting for Revenue Recognition & Compliance Considerations

Proper revenue recognition is among the most critical aspects of accrual accounting, with significant compliance implications.

Revenue recognition under accrual—Key rules

The accounting for revenue recognition model follows five essential steps:

1. Identify the contract with the customer
2. Identify performance obligations within the contract
3. Determine the transaction price
4. Allocate the price to the performance obligations
5. Recognize revenue when each obligation is satisfied

This framework applies across industries but requires careful interpretation for:

• Subscription-based services
• Bundled products and services
• Long-term contracts with milestones
• Variable consideration arrangements
• Right of return provisions

Regulatory insights & common pitfalls

Regulatory compliance requires attention to:

• U.S. GAAP vs. IFRS differences – While converging, these standards still have nuanced differences
• Sales tax considerations – Accrual accounting may change when tax liability occurs
• Audit readiness – Documentation requirements increase under accrual
• Tax timing implications – Book-to-tax differences may require reconciliation

Common pitfalls include:

• Inconsistent application of revenue recognition principles
• Incomplete accrual of expenses at period end
• Failure to properly document accounting policies
• Inadequate systems to capture transaction information

The human side of transition

Beyond technical considerations, the human factors of transition require attention:

• Building team trust through transparent communication about why changes are occurring
• Addressing change management with clear training and support
• Preserving data integrity during the transition process
• Creating psychological safety for staff to raise concerns during implementation

Success depends as much on cultural acceptance as technical execution.

Real-World Case Study & Founder Insights

Learning from others’ experiences provides a valuable perspective when planning your own transition to accrual accounting.

Case study: TechCo’s switch to accrual  accounting

TechCo grew from $700K to $3M in annual revenue and needed clearer cash-flow forecasting. After adopting accrual accounting, they reduced forecasting errors by 20% and streamlined their audit process.

The company’s transition revealed several key insights:

• Initial setup required more time than anticipated (12 weeks vs. 8 planned)
• Staff training needed reinforcement after 60 days
• The improved visibility into customer payment patterns allowed for targeted collection strategies
• Lenders responded positively to the more sophisticated financial reporting

Jennifer’s first-person reflection

When I led the rollout at Complete Controller, we aligned our clients’ finance teams with clear SOPs and saw a 30% reduction in month-end close time. The most significant challenge wasn’t technical—it was getting everyone comfortable with a new perspective on financial performance.

I remember one client who initially resisted the change because their cash accounting method had served them for years. Six months after transitioning, they called to thank me because they had discovered a product line that appeared profitable under cash accounting but was actually losing money when all costs were properly matched to revenue.

Actionable takeaways from Complete Controller’s founder

From my experience guiding hundreds of businesses through this transition, here are my essential recommendations:

• Leverage cloud-based bookkeeping platforms with built-in accrual modules to simplify the transition
• Schedule monthly variance analyses to catch discrepancies early and build confidence in new reports
• Communicate value to stakeholders by showing real numbers that reflect business performance
• Develop a reconciliation routine that allows you to explain differences between cash and accrual results
• Start with revenue recognition as your first focus area, then expand to expense accruals

The businesses that thrive post-transition are those that embrace accrual accounting not just as a compliance requirement but as a strategic advantage.

Conclusion

Switching from cash to accrual accounting represents a pivotal evolution in your business’s financial maturity. The transition signals not just compliance with accounting standards but readiness for sophisticated decision-making based on true business performance.

As revenue grows beyond $1 million, as inventory becomes significant, or as you seek external financing, accrual accounting provides the visibility and accuracy needed to navigate increasing complexity. While the implementation requires investment in systems and training, the returns in forecasting accuracy, profitability insights, and stakeholder confidence typically deliver substantial value.

Whether you’re responding to lender requirements or proactively preparing for growth, a structured implementation approach minimizes disruption while maximizing benefits. Ready to transform your financial visibility and decision-making capability? Visit Complete Controller for expert guidance from the team that pioneered cloud-based bookkeeping and controller services.

FAQ

What triggers a requirement to switch to accrual accounting?

Legal requirements to switch typically occur when your business exceeds $25 million in gross receipts (under current tax law), maintains inventory as a material income-producing factor, or operates as a C-Corporation with over $5 million in revenue. Additionally, seeking external financing, preparing for an acquisition, or planning for an IPO generally necessitates accrual accounting.

Can small businesses stay on a cash basis forever?

Legally, yes—if they remain under the IRS gross receipts threshold (currently $25 million), don’t maintain inventory as a material income-producing factor, and don’t have specific lender/investor requirements. However, as businesses grow in complexity, cash basis accounting becomes increasingly inadequate for meaningful financial analysis and decision-making, regardless of legal requirements.

How difficult is the transition from cash to accruals?

The difficulty depends on your business complexity and current systems. For service businesses with short billing cycles, the transition may be relatively straightforward. For companies with inventory, long-term contracts, or complex revenue recognition, expect a 2-3 month implementation with potential assistance from accounting professionals. Cloud-based accounting systems significantly simplify the process compared to legacy systems.

What accounting software supports both methods?

Most modern accounting systems support both cash and accrual methods, including QuickBooks (Online and Desktop), Xero, Sage, NetSuite, and FreshBooks. The difference lies in setup and reporting capabilities. Enterprise-level systems like NetSuite and Sage Intacct offer more sophisticated accrual functionality, while smaller business systems like QuickBooks Online provide adequate basics with proper configuration.

Will switching methods affect my tax filings?

Switching accounting methods for tax purposes requires IRS approval via Form 3115 (Application for Change in Accounting Method). The transition may create a one-time adjustment that affects taxable income, potentially spread over multiple years. While your financial statements can use accrual accounting, you might still qualify to file taxes on a cash basis, creating a book-to-tax difference that your accountant would reconcile annually.

Sources

• CompleteController.com. Evolution of Accounting. https://www.completecontroller.com/evolution-of-accounting/
• CompleteController.com. Business Bookkeeping Essentials. https://www.completecontroller.com/business-bookkeeping-essentials/
• CompleteController.com. Accounting Cycle Closure. https://www.completecontroller.com/accounting-cycle-closure/
• David French. (2023). When to Use Accrual Accounting vs Cash Accounting for SMBs. David French CPA. https://davidfrenchcpa.com/when-to-choose-accrual-accounting-vs-cash-accounting/
• FASB.org. Revenue Recognition Standards. https://www.fasb.org/page/PageContent?pageId=/standards/revenue-recognition.html
• FasterCapital. (2025). Cash Versus Accrual Accounting for Emerging Businesses. https://fastercapital.com/content/Cash-Versus-Accrual-Accounting-for-Emerging-Businesses.html
• IRS.gov. Accounting Methods for Businesses. https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/accounting-methods
• Mselah. (2025). 100+ Accounting Statistics & Trends for Unlocking Insights in your Small Business. https://mselah.com/accounting-statistics/
• QuickBooks. (2020). When Should Your Business Switch to Accrual Accounting? QuickBooks Resource Center. https://quickbooks.intuit.com/r/accounting/switch-accrual-accounting
• Rosenberg Chesnov. (2024). Accounting Method Changes Post-TCJA: What Taxpayers and Businesses Must Know. https://rcmycpa.com/accounting-method-changes-post-tcja-what-taxpayers-and-businesses-must-know/
• SBA.gov. Small Business Financials. https://www.sba.gov/business-guide/manage-your-business/small-business-financials
• Wikipedia. (2025). Accrual Accounting in the Public Sector. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accrualaccountinginthepublic_sector

About Complete Controller® – America’s Bookkeeping Experts Complete Controller is the Nation’s Leader in virtual bookkeeping, providing service to businesses and households alike. Utilizing Complete Controller’s technology, clients gain access to a cloud platform where their QuickBooks™️ file, critical financial documents, and back-office tools are hosted in an efficient SSO environment. Complete Controller’s team of certified US-based accounting professionals provide bookkeeping, record storage, performance reporting, and controller services including training, cash-flow management, budgeting and forecasting, process and controls advisement, and bill-pay. With flat-rate service plans, Complete Controller is the most cost-effective expert accounting solution for business, family-office, trusts, and households of any size or complexity. Reviewed By: Brittany McMillen

Brittany McMillen

Brittany McMillen is a seasoned Marketing Manager with a sharp eye for strategy and storytelling. With a background in digital marketing, brand development, and customer engagement, she brings a results-driven mindset to every project. Brittany specializes in crafting compelling content and optimizing user experiences that convert. When she’s not reviewing content, she’s exploring the latest marketing trends or championing small business success.

See Full Bio