By: Jennifer Brazer
Jennifer is the author of From Cubicle to Cloud and Founder/CEO of Complete Controller, a pioneering financial services firm that helps entrepreneurs break free of traditional constraints and scale their businesses to new heights.
Fact Checked By: Brittany McMillen
Benefits of Private Health Insurance: Is It Worth the Cost?
Private health insurance benefits include faster access to medical care, greater choice of healthcare providers, and premium hospital facilities compared to public insurance options. When you have private coverage, you’ll typically wait days instead of weeks for specialist appointments, choose doctors based on your preferences rather than network limitations, and enjoy private hospital rooms with better amenities. While these advantages are significant, they come at a higher cost that each person must evaluate against their specific healthcare needs and financial situation.
Benefits of private health insurance worth the cost
- Private health insurance offers faster medical care access, greater provider choice, and premium facilities, but comes at a higher cost that must be weighed against individual healthcare needs.
- Privately insured patients often receive specialty care in days rather than weeks or months, significantly reducing wait times for consultations and surgeries.
- Private coverage provides freedom to choose specialists based on reputation or expertise without referral requirements, unlike public insurance networks.
- With private insurance, you typically enjoy private hospital rooms, better amenities, and reduced infection risk, creating a more comfortable healing environment.
- Options like HSAs and HRAs can make private coverage more affordable for self-employed individuals while maintaining quality care access.
The Advantages of Private Health Insurance
Overview of private health insurance benefits
Private health insurance gives you speed, choice, and comfort that public systems often can’t match. You’ll get faster appointments, pick your doctors, and stay in nicer facilities. These private health insurance benefits can dramatically improve your healthcare experience by reducing stress during illness and potentially leading to better outcomes.
Post-WWII America saw private insurance enrollment surge from just 9% to over 70% between 1940–1960, driven by employer benefits and union negotiations. This history shows why private coverage became the backbone of American healthcare. Today’s health insurance plans continue this tradition while adding modern protections and benefits.
Faster access to medical care
Nothing matters more during a health crisis than quick treatment. Private insurance typically cuts wait times dramatically compared to public systems. In Germany, a 2020 study found privately insured patients waited just 8 days for specialty care versus 31 days for public patients—nearly four times faster.
This speed advantage applies to everything from initial consultations to complex surgeries. When you’re dealing with a painful condition or worried about a diagnosis, those weeks or months of waiting can feel like an eternity.
Case study: Reduced waiting times with private insurance
In the UK, where the National Health Service (NHS) provides universal coverage, private insurance has become a popular supplement for those wanting to skip lengthy queues. A patient needing knee replacement surgery might wait up to 18 months through the NHS but just 3-4 weeks with private coverage.
The Kings Fund reports that during peak times, private insurance holders in the UK receive treatment up to 12 times faster than those relying solely on public care. This dramatic difference explains why many Britons maintain private coverage despite having access to free public healthcare.
Increased flexibility in provider choice
Public insurance programs typically limit your provider options to their network. Private insurance—especially PPO plans—gives you the freedom to choose specialists based on reputation, location, or personal preference without jumping through referral hoops.
This flexibility becomes crucial when dealing with complex health conditions where finding the right specialist can significantly impact your outcome. You can select doctors based on experience with your specific condition rather than simply taking whoever is assigned to you.
Access to sophisticated facilities and private rooms
Have you ever stayed in a hospital ward with multiple patients? Private insurance often covers stays in private or semi-private rooms, which means better rest, fewer disruptions, and lower infection risks.
Private facilities typically offer upgraded amenities like better food, more comfortable furnishings, and enhanced privacy. While these might seem like luxuries, they contribute significantly to healing and reduce the stress of hospitalization.
Types of Health Insurance Plans: A Guide
Understanding PPO and HMO plans
Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) plans offer greater flexibility by allowing you to see specialists without referrals. You’ll pay more for this freedom—both in premiums and if you choose out-of-network care—but gain valuable control over your healthcare choices.
Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) plans cost less but require you to select a primary care physician who serves as your healthcare “gatekeeper.” You’ll need referrals for specialists and typically can’t see providers outside the network except in emergencies.
According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, HMOs cost an average of $437 less annually than PPOs for individuals. This cost difference represents the trade-off between affordability and flexibility that defines these plan types.
High-deductible plans and health savings accounts
High-deductible health plans (HDHPs) pair lower monthly premiums with higher out-of-pocket costs before insurance kicks in. These plans work well for generally healthy people who want protection from major medical expenses.
The key advantage is eligibility for a Health Savings Account (HSA), which allows you to save pre-tax dollars for medical expenses. HSA funds roll over year to year and can serve as a supplemental retirement account after age 65.
How to Choose the Best Private Health Insurance Plan
Evaluating health coverage options
Finding the right plan requires balancing coverage, cost, and convenience. Start by listing your regular medications, doctors, and any planned procedures. Then check if these are covered in the plans you’re considering.
Don’t just focus on premiums—calculate potential out-of-pocket costs based on your typical healthcare usage. Sometimes a higher premium plan with better coverage saves money overall for frequent healthcare users. Explore different health coverage options to find what suits your personal situation.
Tools from compare private health insurance resources can help you evaluate different plans side-by-side. Look beyond the surface features to understand how each plan would work with your specific health needs and financial situation.
Balancing premiums, deductibles, and coverage
Insurance shopping requires understanding three key numbers:
- Premiums – Your monthly payment
- Deductibles – What you pay before insurance kicks in
- Copays/Coinsurance – Your share of costs after meeting the deductible
Lower premiums typically mean higher deductibles and vice versa. Consider your financial situation: Can you afford higher monthly costs, or would you prefer to pay more if you need care but less each month?
For chronic condition management, choose lower deductibles and copays. For occasional care needs, a higher deductible plan might save money through reduced premiums.
Individual and Family Coverage Options
Individual vs. family plans
Individual plans tailor coverage to one person’s needs. Family plans cover multiple household members under one policy, which simplifies administration and often costs less than multiple individual policies.
Family plans typically have combined and individual deductibles. This means once the family meets its combined deductible, insurance starts covering everyone, even if some members haven’t met their individual deductibles.
Special considerations for children and dependents
Children typically need more preventive care and have different healthcare needs than adults. Look for plans with strong well-child visit coverage, vaccinations, and pediatric dental/vision benefits.
College-age dependents can usually stay on family plans until age 26, thanks to the Affordable Care Act. This provides crucial coverage during the transition to independent adulthood when young adults might otherwise go uninsured.
Considerations for Freelancers and Small Business Owners
Affordable health insurance solutions
Being self-employed doesn’t mean going without coverage. Individual marketplace plans, professional association group plans, and Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs) offer viable options for entrepreneurs seeking affordable health insurance.
HRAs let small businesses reimburse employees tax-free for individual health insurance premiums instead of offering traditional group plans. This approach gives employees flexibility while helping business owners control costs.
Health reimbursement arrangements (HRAs)
HRAs are gaining popularity among small businesses. A 2024 case study from Take Command Health showcased a 30-employee tech startup that saved $200 per employee monthly by switching from group insurance to a Qualified Small Employer HRA (QSEHRA).
This arrangement allowed employees to choose individual plans suited to their needs while the company provided tax-free reimbursement. The result was a 40% reduction in healthcare costs while maintaining quality coverage. HRAs represent a win-win for employees seeking personalized plans and businesses looking to control expenses.
Comparing Private Health Insurance to Public Options
Private vs. public health insurance: A comparison
Public health insurance like Medicare offers broad access at lower direct costs but often with more restrictions and longer wait times. Private insurance provides greater choice and faster access but at higher monthly costs.
A historical example comes from the UK, which introduced tax subsidies for private insurance in 1991, costing £135 million annually. The program was discontinued in 1997 when analysis showed it failed to reduce NHS strain, highlighting how private health insurance benefits don’t always translate to system-wide improvements.
Medicare supplement plans for seniors
Many seniors combine Original Medicare with private Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans. This hybrid approach leverages Medicare’s comprehensive coverage while using private insurance to fill gaps and reduce out-of-pocket costs.
Medicare Advantage plans, offered by private insurers as an alternative to Original Medicare, often include dental, vision, and prescription coverage that Original Medicare doesn’t provide. These plans show how public and private options can complement each other rather than simply compete.
Making Your Decision: Key Takeaways
Private health insurance offers clear advantages in speed, choice, and comfort—but at a higher cost. Your decision should balance these benefits against your budget, health needs, and personal preferences.
For frequent healthcare users, those with specialist needs, or people prioritizing comfort and convenience, private insurance often justifies its cost. For those with limited healthcare needs who prioritize affordability, public options might be sufficient.
I’ve guided many clients through this decision process at Complete Controller. What I’ve learned is that healthcare choices are deeply personal—there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The right plan is one that gives you peace of mind about your healthcare without creating financial strain.
Ready to make smarter financial decisions about your healthcare and other important aspects of your business? Visit Complete Controller for expert bookkeeping, controller, and financial management services that help you maximize every dollar while protecting what matters most.
FAQ
What exactly does private health insurance cover that public insurance doesn’t?
Private health insurance typically covers shorter wait times for appointments and procedures, access to a wider network of doctors and specialists, private hospital rooms, and sometimes experimental treatments not covered by public insurance. Many private plans also offer better coverage for dental, vision, and mental health services.
How much more expensive is private health insurance compared to public options?
Private health insurance generally costs 20-50% more than public options in monthly premiums. For example, while Medicare Part B costs about $170 monthly for most people, comparable private coverage might cost $350-500 monthly. However, the total cost difference depends on your usage, as private plans may have lower out-of-pocket costs for certain services.
Can I have both private insurance and Medicare at the same time?
Yes, you can have both, but there are specific rules about which insurance pays first. If you have Medicare and employer-based private insurance, the primary payer depends on the employer’s size. You typically cannot buy a new Marketplace plan if you already have Medicare, and you may lose premium tax credits if you keep both.
Are prescription drugs better covered under private or public health insurance?
Private insurance often provides more comprehensive prescription drug coverage, especially for newer medications. While Medicare Part D covers prescriptions, it has a coverage gap (donut hole) and may not include all drugs. Private plans typically offer more extensive formularies and sometimes lower copays, though they usually have higher monthly premiums.
How do I know if switching to private health insurance is worth it for my situation?
Calculate your typical annual healthcare expenses (including premiums, deductibles, and copays) under both options. Consider factors beyond cost: Do you need to see specialists frequently? Do you want specific doctors not covered by public plans? Is privacy important during hospital stays? If the benefits align with your priorities and the cost difference is manageable within your budget, private insurance may be worth it.
Sources
- Morrisey, Michael. “Health Insurance.” ACHE Management Series, 2021, www.ache.org/publications/health-insurance
- Kings Fund. “The NHS In Crisis: Understanding Healthcare System Challenges.” 2023, www.kingsfund.org.uk/publications/nhs-crisis
- Kaiser Family Foundation. “2019 Employer Health Benefits Survey.” KFF.org, 2019, www.kff.org/health-costs/report/employer-health-benefits-annual-survey-archives
- Take Command Health. “HRA Case Studies: Small Business Success Stories.” 2024, www.takecommandhealth.com/case-studies
- Heinrich, Niklas et al. “Waiting Times for Outpatient Treatment in Germany.” EconStor, 2020, www.econstor.eu/handle/10419/219317
- Healthcare.gov. “Choose a Health Insurance Plan.” U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, www.healthcare.gov/choose-a-plan
- Medicare.gov. “Compare Health Insurance Plans.” U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, www.medicare.gov
- Wikipedia. “Health Insurance.” Wikimedia Foundation, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_insurance
- Complete Controller Blog. “Private Health Insurance Benefits.” Complete Controller, www.completecontroller.com/blog
- Complete Controller. “6 Amazing Benefits of Life Insurance.” Complete Controller, www.completecontroller.com/6-amazing-benefits-of-life-insurance
- Complete Controller. “Gain Your Freedom with Freelancing.” Complete Controller, www.completecontroller.com/gain-your-freedom-with-freelancing
- PeopleKeep. “How HRAs Work.” PeopleKeep.com, www.peoplekeep.com/hra-guide
- ValuePenguin. “Medicare vs. Private Insurance: A Comprehensive Comparison.” ValuePenguin.com, www.valuepenguin.com/insurance/medicare-vs-private-insurance
- EHealthInsurance. “Compare Private Insurance Plans.” eHealthInsurance.com, www.ehealthinsurance.com/resources/compare-plans
About Complete Controller® – America’s Bookkeeping Experts Complete Controller is the Nation’s Leader in virtual bookkeeping, providing service to businesses and households alike. Utilizing Complete Controller’s technology, clients gain access to a cloud platform where their QuickBooks™️ file, critical financial documents, and back-office tools are hosted in an efficient SSO environment. Complete Controller’s team of certified US-based accounting professionals provide bookkeeping, record storage, performance reporting, and controller services including training, cash-flow management, budgeting and forecasting, process and controls advisement, and bill-pay. With flat-rate service plans, Complete Controller is the most cost-effective expert accounting solution for business, family-office, trusts, and households of any size or complexity.
