By: Jennifer Brazer
Jennifer is the author of From Cubicle to Cloud and Founder/CEO of Complete Controller, a pioneering financial services firm that helps entrepreneurs break free of traditional constraints and scale their businesses to new heights.
Fact Checked By: Brittany McMillen
Subcontract vs. Hire: The Best Choice for Your Accounting Needs
Accounting subcontract or hire decisions depend on your business size, budget constraints, and specific financial needs—subcontracting offers flexibility and specialized expertise for project-based work while hiring provides consistent daily oversight and deeper integration with company culture. The right choice directly impacts your bottom line, with outsourcing typically saving 20-50% compared to full-time employees when you factor in salaries, benefits, training costs, and overhead expenses.
As the founder of Complete Controller, I’ve guided over 500 businesses through this critical decision over the past 20 years. One tech startup client slashed their accounting costs by 40% through strategic subcontracting while maintaining an in-house CFO for high-level strategy—a hybrid approach that transformed their cash flow. This article breaks down the real costs, compliance considerations, and strategic frameworks that will help you make the smartest choice for your unique situation, whether you’re a bootstrapped startup or an established company ready to scale.
What’s the best choice for your accounting needs: Subcontract or hire?
- Subcontract for specialized expertise, variable workloads, and cost savings of 20-50%; hire for daily oversight and consistent financial operations
- Subcontracting eliminates employee benefits, payroll taxes, and training costs while providing access to niche skills
- Hiring builds institutional knowledge and ensures tighter data control for sensitive financial information
- Hybrid models combine the best of both worlds—outsource routine tasks while keeping strategic roles in-house
- Your decision should align with business size, growth trajectory, and compliance requirements
Understanding the Core Differences: Subcontracting vs. Hiring
The fundamental distinction between subcontracting and hiring lies in the employment relationship and cost structure. Subcontractors operate as independent businesses, managing their own taxes, benefits, and professional development while charging you only for completed work. Employees become part of your organizational structure, receiving regular paychecks, benefits packages, and direct supervision while building long-term loyalty to your company.
Control levels vary dramatically between these options. With subcontractors, you define the deliverables and deadlines but cannot dictate how, when, or where they complete the work—they maintain complete autonomy over their methods and schedules. Employees work under your direct supervision, following company procedures, using your systems, and adhering to set schedules that align with your business operations.
The financial implications extend beyond simple hourly rates. A $50,000 salary actually costs employers approximately $78,000 when you include payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, health insurance, retirement contributions, and paid time off. Subcontractors handle all these expenses independently, charging higher hourly rates that still result in lower total costs for businesses needing specialized or intermittent services.
The Financial Reality: Breaking Down True Costs
Smart financial analysis reveals that outsourcing accounting saves businesses 20-50% compared to maintaining in-house teams. These savings stem from eliminated recruitment costs, reduced training expenses, no benefits packages, and avoided overhead for office space and equipment. A retail startup might invest $3,000 monthly for comprehensive outsourced bookkeeping instead of $6,000 for a full-time accountant’s total compensation package.
Hidden costs of hiring extend beyond the obvious salary and benefits. Companies spend an average of $4,000 to recruit each new employee, invest 40 hours in initial training, and lose productivity during the 3-6 month ramp-up period. Additional expenses include software licenses, continuing education, management time for supervision, and potential severance costs if the hire doesn’t work out.
Subcontracting delivers predictable costs with built-in flexibility. You pay only for actual work completed, scale services up or down based on seasonal needs, and avoid long-term financial commitments. During tax season, you might triple your accounting support without permanent payroll increases, then reduce to maintenance levels during slower periods.
Case study: Manufacturing success through strategic outsourcing
A growing manufacturing startup partnered with Farche Solutions to outsource payroll and tax compliance while maintaining one in-house controller for strategic planning. This hybrid approach reduced their accounting costs by 30%, eliminated compliance errors that previously triggered audits, and freed up $50,000 annually for product development. The key to their success: keeping daily financial oversight internal while leveraging external expertise for specialized, rules-based tasks.
Navigating Compliance and Legal Requirements
Misclassifying employees as independent contractors can trigger IRS penalties of $1,000 per worker, with 40% of unpaid employment taxes stemming from classification errors. The IRS examines behavioral control, financial arrangements, and relationship factors to determine proper classification. If you control when, where, and how work gets done, you likely have an employee regardless of your preferred label.
Protecting your business requires clear contractor agreements specifying project scope, deliverables, payment terms, and intellectual property rights. Include confidentiality clauses, data security requirements, and termination procedures. Require proof of business insurance and verify their business entity status through state databases.
Employee compliance involves different obligations: workers’ compensation coverage, unemployment insurance contributions, overtime pay requirements, and adherence to labor laws. While more complex, these requirements provide legal clarity and reduce audit risks. Document all employment policies, maintain accurate time records, and conduct regular compliance reviews.
Strategic Decision Framework for Your Business
Statistics show 37% of small and medium businesses now outsource accounting functions, with cost savings cited as the primary driver by 65% of companies. Your optimal choice depends on several critical factors that require honest assessment.
- Business Size and Complexity Analysis: Companies under $5 million in revenue typically benefit most from subcontracting due to variable workloads and budget constraints. Growing firms between $5-20 million often adopt hybrid models, combining outsourced bookkeeping with in-house financial leadership. Larger organizations usually bring core accounting in-house while subcontracting specialized projects.
- Workload Consistency Evaluation: Map your accounting tasks by frequency and complexity. Daily transaction processing, weekly reporting, and monthly closings suggest hiring needs. Quarterly tax filings, annual audits, and periodic system implementations align with subcontracting advantages. Calculate hours needed monthly—if under 80 hours, subcontracting likely offers better value.
- Total Cost of Ownership Calculation: Compare all-in costs including salaries, benefits (add 25-40%), recruiting expenses, training time, software licenses, and management overhead against subcontractor quotes. Factor in flexibility value—the ability to scale quickly without severance costs or unemployment claims has real monetary worth during economic uncertainty.
When Subcontracting Delivers Maximum Value
Project-based initiatives create ideal subcontracting opportunities. System conversions, acquisition due diligence, or IPO preparation require specialized expertise for defined timeframes. Paying premium rates for 3-month engagements beats hiring specialists you won’t need long-term.
Seasonal peaks demand flexible staffing solutions. Retail businesses processing 40% of annual revenue during the holidays can add subcontracted support for October through January. Tax firms scale up during filing season. Construction companies need extra help during summer building booms.
Specialized expertise requirements favor subcontracting when you need niche knowledge occasionally. International tax compliance, forensic accounting investigations, or industry-specific regulations might require monthly consultation rather than full-time staff. Access top talent without competing for permanent hires in tight labor markets.
Building Your In-House Advantage
Data sensitivity in healthcare, financial services, or government contracting often mandates internal accounting teams. When client information requires strict access controls and audit trails, employees provide better security through background checks, ongoing supervision, and legal accountability.
Companies experiencing rapid growth need dedicated financial professionals who understand evolving business models, can adapt systems in real-time, and provide strategic input during leadership meetings. An invested employee who grows with your company brings institutional knowledge that contractors cannot replicate.
Cultural alignment and team integration matter when accounting interfaces with multiple departments daily. Employees attend company meetings, understand internal politics, and build relationships that facilitate smooth operations. They become trusted advisors who anticipate needs rather than simply responding to requests.
Future-Proofing Your Financial Operations
Automation will handle 40% of traditional accounting tasks by 2025, fundamentally shifting the subcontract versus hire equation. Routine data entry, bank reconciliations, and basic reporting increasingly require less human involvement. This technological evolution makes specialized subcontractors more valuable for analytical work while reducing the need for entry-level employees.
Progressive companies adopt hybrid models that leverage both employment types strategically. They maintain lean in-house teams focused on strategy, analysis, and stakeholder relationships while outsourcing transactional processing, compliance filings, and technical projects. This structure provides stability, expertise, and scalability.
AI integration changes required skillsets dramatically. Modern accounting professionals must interpret AI-generated insights, identify anomalies in automated processes, and provide strategic context that machines cannot. Subcontractors often lead adoption curves, bringing cutting-edge tools and techniques without requiring your investment in training or technology.
Final Thoughts
The choice between subcontracting and hiring accounting support shapes your company’s financial efficiency, compliance posture, and growth potential. Through two decades of building Complete Controller, I’ve learned that dogmatic approaches fail—successful businesses thoughtfully blend both options based on specific needs, growth stages, and industry requirements.
Start by auditing your current accounting workload, calculating true costs, and identifying which tasks require daily oversight versus periodic expertise. Most thriving companies discover that hybrid models deliver optimal results: maintaining core financial leadership internally while leveraging specialized subcontractors for variable workloads and technical projects.
Your next step is clear: assess your unique situation using the frameworks provided, then design a financial team structure that balances cost efficiency with operational excellence. For personalized guidance on optimizing your accounting operations through strategic staffing decisions, connect with our experts at Complete Controller. We’ll help you build a financial backbone that scales with your ambitions while protecting your bottom line.
Frequently Asked Questions About Accounting: Subcontract or Hire
How do I protect sensitive financial data when working with subcontractors?
Require subcontractors to sign comprehensive non-disclosure agreements, use encrypted file-sharing platforms, limit access to only necessary systems, and verify their data security protocols through third-party certifications like SOC 2 compliance audits.
Can I transition a subcontractor to an employee if my needs change?
Yes, many businesses start with subcontractors to validate workload demands and cultural fit before offering full-time positions. Document the relationship change clearly, adjust tax withholdings immediately, and provide appropriate benefits to avoid compliance issues.
What’s the biggest legal mistake businesses make with contractor classification?
Exercising too much control over subcontractors’ work methods, schedules, or requiring exclusive relationships triggers employee classification. The IRS focuses on who controls how work gets performed, not just payment structure.
Do subcontractors handle year-end tax preparation and filing?
Subcontractors prepare and provide Form 1099-NEC documentation, but businesses remain responsible for filing these forms with the IRS by January 31st and maintaining accurate records of all payments exceeding $600 annually.
How does AI adoption impact the decision to subcontract versus hire?
AI automates routine bookkeeping tasks, making entry-level positions less necessary while increasing demand for specialized subcontractors who can implement, optimize, and interpret AI-driven financial systems for strategic decision-making.
Sources
- Better Accounting. (2025). “Hiring vs. Outsourcing Accountant.” URL: https://betteraccounting.com/hiring-vs-outsourcing
- Brady CFO. (2025). “Outsourcing Accounting Services vs. Hiring Internally.” URL: https://bradycfo.com/outsourcing-vs-hiring
- CFO Hub. (2024). “Hiring an Accounting Manager? Why You Should Outsource Instead.” URL: https://cfohub.com/outsource-vs-hire
- Complete Controller. (2024). “Accounting Subcontract or Hire?” URL: https://www.completecontroller.com/accounting-subcontract-or-hire
- Cook CPA Group. (2025). “How to Account for Independent Contractors.” URL: https://cookcpagroup.com/independent-contractors
- Deloitte. (2024). “AI in Finance.” URL: https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/finance/articles/ai-in-finance.html
- DPE AFL-CIO. (2025). “Misclassification of Employees as Independent Contractors.” URL: https://www.dpeaflcio.org/factsheets/misclassification-of-employees-as-independent-contractors
- DVF CPA. (2025). “Hiring an Accounting Firm.” URL: https://dvfcpa.com/hiring-accounting-firm
- Farche Solutions. (2024). “Cost Savings and Business Growth Through Outsourcing Accounting.” URL: https://farchesolutions.com/franchising/cost-savings-and-business-growth
- Gentle Frog. (2025). “Bookkeeping Subcontracting: Expectations vs. Reality.” URL: https://gentlefrog.com/bookkeeping-subcontracting
- Housecall Pro. (2024). “Subcontractor vs. Employee.” URL: https://housecallpro.com/subcontractor-vs-employee
- Invedus. (2024). “Top Accounting Outsourcing Trends You Need to Know for 2025.” URL: https://invedus.com/blog/top-accounting-outsourcing-trends
- Investopedia. (2024). “Total Cost of Ownership.” URL: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/t/totalcostofownership.asp
- IRS. (2024). “Independent Contractor Self-Employed or Employee.” URL: https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/independent-contractor-self-employed-or-employee
- Lucey Accounting. (2022). “To Hire or Not to Hire.” URL: https://luceyaccounting.com/to-hire-or-not
- NOW CFO. (2025). “Outsourcing Accounting For Business Growth.” URL: https://nowcfo.com/outsourcing-accounting-growth
- Personiv. (2025). “Learn How to Maximize Accounting Outsourcing Cost Savings.” URL: https://insights.personiv.com/blog-personiv/accounting-outsourcing-cost-savings
- Reconciled Solutions. (2025). “Subcontractors vs. Employees.” URL: https://reconciledsolutions.com/subcontractors-vs-employees
- Tesseon. (2023). “Subcontractor vs. Employee.” URL: https://tesseon.com/subcontractor-vs-employee
- TGG Accounting. (2024). “Outsourced Accounting vs. Hiring In-House.” URL: https://tggaccounting.com/outsourced-vs-in-house
- TMD Accounting. (2022). “Bookkeeping for Independent Contractors.” URL: https://tmdaccounting.com/bookkeeping-contractors
- Voolt. (2024). “Subcontractor vs. Employee.” URL: https://voolt.com/subcontractor-vs-employee